Commitment


I wrote a post yesterday about getting back on the dating horse. But I’m not so sure I want to. Life is peaceful now. There is no daily drama. I’m not constantly irritated and frustrated. I’m content. In contrast, a little over a year ago, I wrote this:

It’s May 22, 2011. Mack and I have spent my birthday weekend at the beach. His asshole side made an appearance last night, and I did not indulge him. We were singing in the car on the way to getting my oozy chocolate birthday dessert. I thought we were having a good time with it, when suddenly he snapped at me. He said this is his profession and he doesn’t indulge mere amateurs by singing with them whilst driving in a car. He said at first it was fun, but then he found me obnoxious. By this time we were at the restaurant. He got out of the car in a huff, like he had been put upon and was totally justified in being a prick. I got out of the car after some deliberation, and told him I didn’t want to go into the restaurant. He said, “Fine!” We got in the car and as he exited the parking lot, he gunned the engine a little. I told him I’d drive, if he was going to drive like an idiot. Again, “Fine!” So we switched seats and I drove us home. When we got home, he got out of the car and went for a walk on the beach. I wanted to. But since he announced it first, I simply went to bed. He came back a short time later and slammed around in the kitchen, loudly and angrily, making sure he made his ire known. I dozed in and out, and eventually he came into the bedroom, demanding that I wake up. “Why, so you can yell at me some more?” He left me alone after that. Later he came back to bed, and said, “Great, I sleep this way in two beds now.” Realizing what he’d said, he added, “At least I used to.” So, either he still sleeps in bed with Corrine, or he threw it out there erroneously, trying to make a point in the midst of his anger.

He gave up sleeping and went out in the living room to work on my computer. And read about Galveston. He came to bed a couple of hours later. I slept in my clothes.

I arose before he did, and found a note in the kitchen that he’d fixed my laptop. And the coffee was ready, just flip the switch. But there was no apology. At least not an overt one. He got up shortly after I did. I was still in the midst of my first cup. I was out on the deck, typing on my laptop. He asked if my computer was working. I nodded my head that it was. Shortly thereafter I went inside to refill my coffee.

He said, “So what happens now?”

“I’m drinking coffee, enjoying the morning on the deck.” I paused. Refilled my cup. “Unless you want to yell at me some more and tell me how obnoxious I am.”

“Not really.”

I went back out on the deck with my refilled cup and began writing. I imagined him inside. Pouting.

Last night I didn’t like him at all. I knew we were done. I found him unattractive, and I didn’t want him to touch me. This morning, standing there in the middle of the room, he looked young. Vulnerable. Cute. Maybe it’s not over. Maybe you deal with someone being a complete asshole from time to time.

From time to time, I read back over things I wrote back then, and I wonder what in the hell I was thinking.

That kind of assholeishness isn’t normal in a relationship, is it? Is this the way people behave and it’s just swept under the rug and forgotten? I really do not know. Which is how I kept talking myself into staying.

I had no role models growing up for this sort of thing. My role models taught me that you’re honest, you don’t steal, you don’t lie, and you don’t cheat people. You get a good education and you work hard. I was taught the value of a dollar. I was taught that reading books is magical.

But I wasn’t taught that you treat your partner with kindness and respect. My father treated my mother horribly. He ridiculed her constantly. He told her she was fat. He made fun of her when she ate. He’d say things like, “Just keep eating, Joanna, just keep eating!” She never said a word. But I’d defend her. Some of the worst fights I ever had with my father began when I defended my mother. And those fights were always my fault–because I antagonized him.

I once pressed my mother to explain why she never fought back. She said it was much easier to simply ignore him. I asked her how she could possibly ignore the daily onslaughts, the horrible ridicule. She said she’d just learned to tune him out.

And I was tuning out Mack’s bad behavior. Only it didn’t work for me like it worked for my mother. And so I broke free of him. And once I was free, once I could let go of everything I’d bottled up for a year, I fell into a depression.

And now, here I am, feeling better, and wondering: Do I get involved in another relationship? How do I know he won’t be another Mack? How will I know if he’s a kind, respectful man, and not a man simply on his best behavior for a few months? If he treats me poorly, when do I run? At the first instance? The second? And how poorly does he have to treat me for it to not be normal? I need a role model. Or a book. Is there a book out there that gives examples of what’s acceptable and what isn’t in a relationship?

Is there a book out there telling me what’s normal, and what’s not?

One year ago today. Mack and I were making up after a breakup. On my office floor. He allowed himself to reunite with me, but only after I apologized and groveled after breaking up with him. Because he was wearing me out with all the arguments over imagined slights. Over his jealousy of a man I dated four years earlier. And because he lived with another woman. His “roommate.” (But no jealousy for me. My suspicions were going to kill our relationship.) So many lies. So many unbelievable lies that I pretended to believe. Why? To have a man around. It was the beginning of another “honeymoon” phase. And I wanted to believe his lies. I wanted the engagement ring I wore to mean something. I wanted the fantasy to be real.

I can’t afford to believe lies any more. There’s too much at stake.

This blog began as a way to sort through my feelings about a difficult relationship. It then became a blog about ending that relationship; an ending I initiated. Finally, it morphed into a blog about recovering from an abusive relationship and depression. Blogging is good stuff. Were it not for blogging, I might still be wringing my hands, questioning whether I did the right thing when I ended the relationship, and perhaps even being sucked back in by Mack’s manipulation.

Back in January, I wrote about how long it might take to get over ending things with Mack. http://wp.me/p1jL9y-34 The standard formula is half the time you were in the relationship. Mack and I were “together” for a year. I broke it off with him in late September. According to that formula, I should be in recovery until late March.

But the formula is stupid. Take these examples:

  • I’ve been married to a man I detest for 20 years. The moment the last kid finally heads off to college, I call the lawyer I’ve had waiting in the wings for the past 5 years. Do you really think it’s going to take me 10 years to recover from the divorce?
  • I’m married to the love of my life for 6 years. He’s honest, kind, and the funniest man I’ve ever known. We’ve had lots of grand adventures, and respect each other immensely. He dies of pancreatic cancer. Am I going to be over him in 3 years? I doubt it. I probably never will be over him.
  • I’ve lived with an emotionally abusive prick for 16 years. He’s got my head so fucked up I don’t know who I am any more. My self-confidence is virtually non-existent, and I’m convinced (with loads of help from him) no other man will ever love me. He doesn’t have a job and I support him financially. Even so, he leaves me for someone new. Will I be over him in 8 years? With the help of a therapist and a good support system, maybe. But the odds are high I’ll take him back in a heartbeat when his new love throws him out, having realized what an abusive, manipulative motherfucker he is. (True story.)

The truth is, the formula for getting over a breakup looks more like this:

There simply are so many variables, there can’t be a one-size-fits-all formula.

Even though there is no time certain when you’ll be over your breakup, there are things you can do to speed the process.

  • The number one most important thing you can do to heal from a breakup, and I cannot stress this enough, is to cut off all communication.

This is particularly important when your ex is abusive or manipulative. No communication means you don’t meet him for a drink to hash through things yet again, you don’t call him (even if your brother is dying), you don’t return his calls, you don’t send email, you delete his email without replying, you unfriend him on Facebook, Twitter, etc., and if necessary, you block him. No communication means no communication. Zero. Zip. Nada.

  • If your ex was abusive, you’re probably going to need a shrink. Get one.

There’s no sense in attempting on your own to unravel the wad of shit you’ll no doubt need to sort through. A therapist also can make sure you don’t engage in too much self-recrimination for being with an abusive asshole to begin with. These guys are practiced at the art of manipulation and deception. Give yourself a break.

  • Get rid of reminders.

If you can’t bring yourself to toss them just yet, bury them in the back of a drawer. I buried the engagement ring in the back of a bathroom drawer. Why the bathroom? Possibly because he’s a douche.

  • Self-care is important for healing. We should take good care of ourselves all the time, but it’s especially important when you’re healing from a breakup.

    • Get plenty of sleep.
    • Feed yourself healthful, nutritious foods. (Feeding yourself well is the most basic form of self-care.)
    • Cut back on the alcohol. You know why: alcohol is a depressant and also it leads to drinking and dialing. Don’t risk it.
    • Get regular exercise, even if it’s just 15 minutes a day. You don’t have to do an all-out cardio workout for now if you don’t quite have the energy. You can go for a walk or roll out your yoga mat. Exercising outdoors is especially helpful for improving your mental state. Exposure to sun and nature is proven to help lift our spirits.
    • Get massages. If you can’t afford one, you can give yourself a massage with a foam roller. There are lots of videos on how to do this on YouTube. There are even a videos on how to make your own foam roller.
    • Take bubble baths with aromatherapy. I am particularly fond of Aura Cacia’s Lavender Harvest Bubble Bath. It makes lots of beautifully scented bubbles.
  • Plan a vacation or something to which you’ll look forward with anticipation.

I just booked a 10-night solo trip to Tuscany, somewhere I’ve always wanted to go. A trip fling with a tall, dark, and handsome Italian would certainly speed the healing process. See this hilarious classic SNL skit featuring Kirstie Alley at Il Cantore restaurant. http://www.hulu.com/watch/3521/saturday-night-live-il-cantore-resaurant) You might want to avoid Paris, however. Everywhere you go, people are kissing. There even are web postings on the best places in Paris to kiss. http://www.bonjourparis.com/story/the-best-places-to-kiss-in-paris/ I’m thinking they could do a best-places-to-masturbate-in-Paris post, and expand their market.

  • Make a list of negative things about your ex. Review it often.

If you were the dumper, this should be easy. If you were the dumpee, it might be harder. But try. If you need help, ask your friends. They see lots of things we miss whilst doing the ostrich.

I can’t have you missing out on ostrich cuteness while you’re recovering from your breakup, so I give you this, also:

  • Blog.

Lots of experts recommend journaling. But why journal when you can blog? When you journal, you’re on your own. But when you blog, you run across people going through similar challenges. I’ve found comfort in learning the ball of shit I’m sifting through is not so unique. It makes me feel less alone.

And less damaged.

Personal experience has taught me time and again that chemistry is not necessarily a good thing when it comes to choosing a romantic partner. When I feel that inexplicable pull to be with someone I otherwise wouldn’t imagine dating in a post-nuclear world, that’s a pretty good sign bad chemistry is at work.

Mack and I had been communicating on-line for months. He’d been following me (and multiple other women) around on a fitness website. Eventually we began sending private messages, and a few months later we made plans to meet in person. Well, actually, he made plans for us to meet, and I complied. And so it began. I was eager to meet him. I’d actually fallen for him simply trading emails. The man he created through those emails was very enticing. He fancied himself a musician, and a writer. Most of it turned out to be but a figment of his imagination, but the personal mystique he created with the words he wrote to me had done its job–he’d drawn me in.

Mack had me meet him at a shitty dive bar on the seedier side of town. I could do dive bars, or so I told myself. When I walked in, he jumped up from the booth where he’d been sitting, watching the door and drinking a beer. (One of many, no doubt.) As he came toward me like an eager puppy, my heart fell. Physically he was not my type at all. He was wearing 80s-style jeans and a gray “wife-beater.” (A  foreshadowing, of sorts.) Although his appearance was course and unrefined, my misgivings were overshadowed by his physicality, his sexuality, his confidence. I speculated that there had to be a reason for his confidence. There had to be a reason he thought he fit with a successful, professional, urbane woman. (Later I would discover there wasn’t one, other than an absurd sense of entitlement that is common to many abusers.) I had to figure out why I was drawn to this guy. Why I felt such chemistry with a man I would never have seen myself with. I told myself that I should give a different sort of man a chance. I talked myself into it, against my better judgment. (I ignored my gut. Always a bad idea.)

Being with Mack felt familiar from the start. It was all so easy. I felt comfortable with him, as if I had always known him. I felt he knew me. All of me. Even the parts of me I imagined were damaged. The connection was on a much deeper level than it should have been at this early stage (another clue that something was wrong). Mack said being with me was like coming home. I said, I felt it, too.

Coming home. Home for me was not a safe place. Home for me was an abusive alcoholic father and a manipulative mother who adored playing the martyr. Home was painful. Home left me bruised and battered, emotionally and physically. Yet being with Mack felt like coming home; a place I’d avoided since early adulthood. Mack once expressed pride in the fact that he blended so well with my family. As if that were a selling point. Later I would ponder this comment, and begin to see why I was drawn to and repulsed by Mack, seemingly simultaneously.

When things were at their worst with Mack, after many months of manipulation and emotional abuse, I told myself this is the kind of relationship I was doomed to have. Because I was damaged in my childhood, this is the only kind of man I could pair with. I told myself we both were fucked up in the same ways, and so we fit. And this was my life. It was either this, or being alone. Now that I’ve been away from Mack for several months, I see that I’d been severely mindfucked. Mack would tell me that no other man would love me like he does. No other man would appreciate my body the way he does. (Like many women, I have body image issues, of which Mack was acutely aware, and which he used to manipulate me into thinking I should stay with him because I’d never find another man accepting of my body like he was.) No one else could put up with my “quirks.” After all, I’d always lived alone and so I didn’t know how to live with a man. But he was okay with that. He would work with me. He’d save me from my pathetic life of solitude, to which I was doomed if I left him. When he proposed to me, he said, “Now you don’t have to be alone any more.” This was it. My last chance. He’d even written a song about it, featuring these lyrics: This is our last chance for love. Message received. I’d better keep hold of Mack. Because no other man would put up with me, and my body, and my quirks.

Yes, I’d been mindfucked. And hard. It was a virtual pounding. (Which is ironic seeing he suffered from a severe case of erectile dysfunction.)

I understand now that strong chemistry, or a strong sexual attraction (particularly with someone we can hardly imagine ourselves pairing with), is that primitive need to recreate our unhealthy and dysfunctional childhoods. Strong chemistry often means only that their teeth fit our wounds.

Mack’s teeth fit my wounds. Our chemistry was the worst kind of chemistry. Perhaps next time, I will date an entirely different kind of man: a nice, seemingly boring guy. The kind of guy who in the past, I’ve given short shrift. Yes, nice guys are looking mighty attractive these days. I’ve even begun to feel physically attracted to them. Odd the unintended aftereffects of dating an abusive asshole. Perhaps it wasn’t all for naught, after all.  

As I look at my 2011 Humane Society calendar, knowing there are no pages behind December, I am flooded with relief. What is it about closing out a year that makes us feel we can put our missteps and blunders, regrets and sorrows, behind us? Why is there such heft that comes with beginning a new year? Whether we make resolutions or not, every one of us feels the sense that the new year brings new beginnings. We all feel hope at the chance for something different. Something better. Some of us hope for new love. Some, financial success. Others are going to run that first marathon. Or 5k. Some of us simply are grateful to close the door on painful events that occurred in 2011.

2011, like most years, was a mixed bag for me. I enjoyed the changes at my law firm that brought new energy and life to my practice. While my family presented the usual trials and tribulations that come with alcoholism and other forms of dysfunction, nobody died. We went through an extreme drought in Austin, but for the past couple of months, we’ve had rain. Mack was in my life, there were some good times, but he was very, very bad for me. Not to mention, a complete and utter douche.

It occurs to me that if I had written this blog two weeks ago, before I started the antidepressants, this would have been a very different blog. Now, I see a bit of hope peeking through the clouds.

2012. I don’t care what the Mayans say, I’ve got a strong feeling it’s going to be an exceptional year. In a good way. True, I’ve always liked even-numbered years better, but I think it’s more than that. Or maybe it’s just the antidepressants talking. Either way, I feel so relieved that in a matter of hours, 2011 will be behind me. In the words of our not-so beloved Governor Goodhair a/k/a Rick Perry:

Adios, MoFo.

Can you ever really get free of past relationships? I had it in my head that once I broke things off with Mack for good, I would remake my life and everything was going to be grand. Here I am, nearly three months later, and still I feel terribly stuck. There has to be a trick to overcoming this inertia, but I can’t seem to make any real progress. Is there something I could be doing, or is the trick simply to let time pass? Or maybe even the passage of time won’t do it. Am I doomed to be forever haunted by Mack?

What have I done to get free of Mack? I’ve signed up with a personal trainer, with whom I meet two days a week. I’ve started “running” more consistently. I’ve been drinking less and eating better, although both still could use additional improvement. I’ve cleared my home of most of the reminders of Mack. I did keep a bird statue. I really like birds. I did, of course, toss all things connected to our sex life. Yes, there were quite a few of those. As I’ve mentioned in previous posts, good sex was one thing we had going for us. I’ll probably never have sex like that again, but what can you do?

This morning I went a step further and cleared out the hundreds and hundreds of emails we’ve written to each other over the past year and half. I didn’t delete them, I’m not ready to take that step yet, but I did move them to their own private little folder. I read a few of them as I went along, and was reminded that things with Mack, since the very beginning, were a struggle. We were constantly arguing. About everything. It was exhausting. (One of his favorite topics was my ex-lovers. So apparently, I’m haunted by them, too.) It seems my entire relationship with Mack was one long argument. Followed by make-up sex. Even now, post-breakup, we argue. Only now, there’s no make-up sex, so what the hell is the point?

Oh. Now I see now why getting free of the ghost of Mack has been such an arduous process. It’s because I’m still not post-Mack. He’s still a huge part of my life. Even though I haven’t seen him in months, we’re still email-arguing (followed by make-up email) regularly. It’s almost like we never broke up. This has to stop. Unless I stop communicating with Mack, I’ll never be free.

How do divorced couples with children, who have to continue to communicate, free themselves from their exes? Maybe they don’t. Maybe they’re trapped forever. Maybe we’re all trapped forever, whether we continue to communicate, or not. Maybe, no matter what we do, we are forever haunted by the ghosts of lovers past.

How do you know when a relationship is dead? Even though you’ve torched the whole village and there’s nothing left but smoldering chunks of debris, is it possible there’s a phoenix waiting to rise in tragic beauty from the ashes?

I’ve spent most of this long holiday weekend wondering whether I did the right thing by ending my relationship with Mack. Why I’ve been running a post-mortem all weekend, now, when I ended it over two months ago, is a mystery. Okay, maybe it’s not a mystery. It’s a holiday weekend, and you’re supposed to spend it with family and loved ones. I spent it hunkered down in my condo with my cats. By choice. On top of it being a holiday weekend, my brother recently was diagnosed with mouth cancer. They did surgery to remove the cancer on Wednesday, couldn’t get it all, and so radiation is next. So I’m feeling sorry for myself. I’m all alone Thanksgiving weekend, my brother is sick, and I have no one to comfort me. And, of course, it’s always going to be this way and I’m going to die alone after a sad and lonely life. Alone. Sad. And lonely.

I try to get this alarming self-talk under control by reminding myself that second-guessing and regret is normal post-breakup. To put things in perspective, I remind myself why I ended it. Mack lives with Corinne. I was supposed to make a decision about whether I wanted a man to move in with me based on a half-assed relationship with a man who lives with someone else. Never mind Mack’s protestations that they merely were roommates at this juncture of their sixteen-year relationship. Even if they were merely roommates, Mack still tip-toed around Corinne and as a result, our relationship was never a real relationship. I have no flipping idea how polygamy works. How a man could ever make two women happy at the same time is beyond me. Big Love is bullshit.

So yes, I ended it for good reason. And there’s no phoenix struggling to free itself from the debris. I know this because, since I told him I’d had enough, Mack hasn’t once tried to fan the embers and free the sad broken thing from the pile of rubble. You see, he wasn’t too terribly broken up that I ended it. I don’t know why I was surprised. If I mattered to him, he would have made more of an effort while we still were together.

So really, what I hear under the trash heap of our relationship isn’t a sad, broken little phoenix who just needs us to believe in him to give him life. It’s a skittering pile of cockroaches.

One of the top pieces of advice you’ll give or receive when it comes to relationships: “Don’t ever settle.” Let me tell you something, sister: Everybody settles.

Let’s take my friend Deidra. When I met her she had been married for twenty-something years to the same man and she wanted out. While her ex made a good living, and was stable and reliable, they never had a close, loving partnership. She divorced him and set out on a quest to find a replacement, which she did within two years. I’d never had one husband, so when she found a replacement that quickly, I wondered what the hell? The new man makes a modest living. Deidra would prefer that he made more money, but lets that slide. After all, he’s tall. Deidra was dead set on tall this time around. When Deidra and the new man got engaged, the ring wasn’t what she’d hoped for, the proposal (with his family around) was lame, and she complains that he’s stingy. But she loves him.

Fast forward a year. They’ve moved in together, but haven’t yet set a date for the nuptials. They’ve reached the part of the relationship where things aren’t all great sex and cozy Sunday mornings. One Saturday morning I get a text message from her: “He’s been fucking around.” The tall Adonis had been cheating on her. He had slept with an ex-girlfriend at least once and had been having (at least) a torrid texting relationship with a stripper. Deidra threw him out. After a few months, he moved back in. Deidra didn’t want to be alone. She loved him. And she thought they could work through their issues and it wouldn’t happen again. I hope she’s right.

I don’t know whether Deidra made the right decision. I’m pretty sure she doesn’t know whether she made the right decision. But I do think this qualifies as settling.

Then there’s my neighbor, Penny. She’s in her 60s and she’s married to John. It’s a second marriage for them both. John is never home. For the past two years he’s been living in Hong Kong (amongst other places), chasing the next big business deal that’s going to make them rich. They’re already well off, but John is a gambler. He likes the thrill and the risk of cashing in on multi-million (billion?) dollar business deals. In the process, John has depleted most of their retirement savings, and has left Penny on her own 99% of the time. She won’t leave him. Is she settling?

My friend Morgan got married for the first time in her early 50s. She’s been married less than a year, and was ecstatic to finally have tied the knot. Nevertheless, she tells me over and over how hard marriage is. During the first six months of their marriage, her husband complained about her facial expressions, the way she dressed, and how she wore her hair. He’s an engineer and gets up at 5:00 a.m. She’s a free-lance writer and wants to sleep until 7:00. His 23 year-old son moved in with them, even though he has a job and was fully capable of supporting himself. Morgan has no children, so this was quite an adjustment. Morgan was over 50 and wanted to be married. Surely she wasn’t settling.

I have another friend who’s very social and active and didn’t want children. She married a guy who hates parties, likes to sleep until noon, and has a daughter from a previous marriage. She says if something happens to him, she won’t get married again. I wonder if she settled.

The point is, everybody settles. Everybody. If they say they didn’t settle, they’re lying. No one will ever fit every item on your checklist. The question is, are the checklist items on which you’re compromising the right items?

Mack loves me. No doubt about that. Would he have cheated on me? I don’t know. Would he have left me for another woman? I don’t think so. Would he have depleted our savings on some crazy business deal? No. Would he have wandered off to Asia and left me alone for years at a time? No. Would he have complained about my facial expressions, how I dress, if I put on weight, if my hair was too short? No. Would his children create problems for us? No. He has no children. Would I be settling because Mack has no income? Yes. Could we have worked through our issues if I had let him move in and we had behaved like grown-ups when it came time to discuss areas of conflict? Maybe. But I worried if we hadn’t, where would that have left Mack? I always thought the way for Mack and I to make it was to run off and elope. We’d be married. We’d have to work it out. Yes, you can get out of a marriage. But do you think the girl who’s afraid to get married because she believes it is for life would get divorced in an irrational fit of pique?

But Mack wouldn’t re-propose after the first time we broke off the engagement. And I wouldn’t let him move in. So we settled. We settled on breaking up.

It’s been nine and a half weeks since I broke up with Mack. I keep wondering whether I made a mistake. When Mack asked if it was time we lived together, instead of having a conversation with him about my concerns, I decided unilaterally we couldn’t work through our issues. I decided he would never carry his weight in the relationship; he would never be the partner I need.

Now that some time has passed, I’m beginning to see the problems in our relationship weren’t all Mack. As I type this, it sounds silly that I ever thought it was all Mack. The thing is, I’m no good at this relationship thing. Whenever I get in one, someone’s always bailing. I can’t remember the last time I was in a relationship where the two of us worked through issues, instead of simply deciding things were over.

Mack and I did this early on. He moved in two months to the day after we met. Granted, we’d spent months before we actually met communicating on-line. But still, moving in two months after the first physical meeting is quick. It seemed right, though. We were in the stage of the relationship when everything seemed possible. I had finally found someone who made me feel like I’d come home, every time I was in his arms. So what if he didn’t have a job? So what if he lived with another woman? It felt so right to be with him. I had to be with him all the time. Every damn day.

So Mack moved in. It was hard. I had never lived with a man. Okay, once, briefly, when I was in my twenties. That was twenty years ago. And that cohabitation was intended to be temporary. Because it was intended to be (and was) temporary, I don’t think it really counts. So Mack is the first man I have ever lived with. It was a bit of an adjustment. Every day when I went to work, he was here. Every night when I came home, he was here. Mostly, I loved that. But a part of me felt very anxious.

The things I liked about living with Mack: waking up in the morning with him next to me; leaving in the mornings with him typing away on his laptop at the dining room table; coming home to see his truck parked out front (I hated his raggedy old truck, but I liked that sign he was here); going out for a run in the dark knowing that he’d worry if I didn’t make it home; eating dinner together every night, talking, with at least one cat on the table; lying on the sofa, cuddling and watching tv; going to sleep at night with him next to me.

The things I didn’t like about living with Mack: the mornings he didn’t get up when I got up for work; feeling his anxiety that he might do something I didn’t like, knowing he wasn’t entirely comfortable and was walking on eggshells around me; his going back home to Corinne’s every day; Corinne’s calling him when he was here with me, even though he’d been there working all day. I needed that relationship to be over. It never was.

After Mack had been living with me for six weeks, I came home from the grocery store at the end of a holiday weekend, MLK Day, and he was watching sports on tv. I had gone to the store by myself so I could think about the things that were bugging me, and I had worked up a head of steam while I was shopping. In hindsight, I suppose this was the point in the cohabitation when we should have had a discussion about how things were working out, and what we both needed. Instead I came at him with guns drawn:

“This is not working. We need to talk.” I said it angrily. Hardly the way to begin a discussion if you’re trying to bridge gaps.

Mack responded in kind by packing up and leaving, and going back to Corinne. There was no discussion. And I didn’t try to stop him. His going back to Corinne hurt me deeply. I don’t know that I ever got past that.

So Mack and I failed at our first opportunity to work through conflict. Instead of talking, we ended it. It became a pattern of sorts. And this last breakup was my version of packing my stuff up and leaving without a discussion.

I still don’t know if my real issue with Mack is money. I think it’s something deeper. I think it has a lot to do with fear. In the beginning, he made the fear go away. Mack and I came together, two broken people, and we fit. We were like two pieces of the same fucked up puzzle. And we fit. People outside the relationship, people who insisted on giving me advice (namely of the he’s-not-good-enough-for-you, he’s-using-you ilk), could not see how he made me feel less broken. They couldn’t see that I felt like I’d come home when I was with him.

But feeling understood and safe wasn’t always enough. I wanted Mack to appear to the outside world to be worthy of me. I wanted everyone to see how talented he is. I wanted them to know that he is good enough for me, dammit. What I really wanted was for Mack to write. Whether it was music or prose, and even if he never made a dime doing it, I wanted him to write. I fell in love with him through his writing, and saw parts of him through his writing that he never showed me any other way. I felt he had a gift, and I didn’t want him to squander it. And I wanted to continue to connect with him through his writing.

And here I am, nine and a half weeks post break-up, and I’m still wanting to connect with Mack through writing. Only this time, I’m too late. The time for talking, the time for discussing, was nine and a half weeks ago.

There are two schools of thought on dating post-breakup: (1) It’s good to get right back on the horse to help you get over your ex; and (2) It’s good to stay off the dating horse for a bit and take some time to re-group. I agree with the latter philosophy, and was reminded why this past week.

There are lots of good reasons to not date for a while after a breakup. It’s important to take time to grieve the loss of the relationship. You can’t grieve if you’re distracting yourself with a new man. Taking a break gives you space to re-center and regain your focus. If you haven’t recovered emotionally, you can’t make good decisions about potential new lovers. If you haven’t taken time to consider what went wrong, what worked and what didn’t, you might find yourself repeating the same mistakes in your next relationship or in your choice of partners. Breakups are tumultuous. And the relationship probably was shitty for a while prior to the breakup, which is why you broke up in the first place. The pre-breakup tumult, as well as the tumult of the breakup itself, can throw you off-balance. I found myself not sleeping well, not eating well, drinking too much, and exercising too little. I put on weight. I was surly and distracted. My work suffered. My friendships suffered. Worst of all, my self-esteem suffered.

Whether you broke up with a guy who wasn’t good for you, or a guy who wasn’t good for you broke up with you, you’re likely to have suffered a blow to your self-esteem. With me, it was being slowly worn down by a man who wasn’t really in the relationship, emotionally or otherwise. How could he be, when he lived with another woman? I spent a year in denial about things, and it’s left me wiped out. So here I am, slowly putting myself back together. I’m feeling a little better with each passing day. My sleep is improving, my running endurance slowly is increasing to pre-Mack levels, and I’m slowing down on my wine consumption. Even so, I was reminded this week of yet another reason for postponing dating in the aftermath of a breakup: Going out with a new man might leave you pining for your ex.

Wednesday night I met a man for drinks, and eventually a late dinner. I’d gotten together with Stuart once before, when Mack and I still were together. I wasn’t sneaky about it; I told Mack beforehand. Stuart and I have a lot in common. We went to high school together, and the same undergrad. We went to different law schools, but both ended up in Austin practicing law. When we became friends on Facebook, eventually he suggested we meet for drinks. Although Stuart recently was divorced, he knew I was involved with Mack, and so he knew our meeting was not a date.

Our first meeting was uneventful, save for the fact that being with Stuart was a very different experience from being with Mack. Stuart is a year older than me. Mack is ten years older than me. Stuart is the managing partner of his law firm. Mack has no job, and no career. Stuart is single and lives with no one other than his teenage son. Mack lives with Corinne and despite his protestations, never really was single. Stuart dresses in modern, albeit conservative clothing. Mack was always stuck in the 80s, and no matter how hard I tried to nudge him into the style of the current century, I always felt like I was dating John Oates. The biggest glaring difference between the two of them: Stuart paid the check.

After meeting Stuart for drinks that first time, I became even more disillusioned with Mack. I found it more difficult to rationalize being with a man who had no career, no income, and who lived with another woman. I started feeling really badly about myself. I started berating myself for putting up with Mack’s moods, and temper, and “lifestyle,” for lack of a better word. I started to see my relationship with Mack as my friends saw it, and I wondered why I held on to him. Hell, he wasn’t even very nice to me any more.

Fast forward to Wednesday night. Stuart and I met for drinks at an upscale wine bar; somewhere Mack would never go. I allowed myself to think of Stuart as a potential lover, seeing as I’m single now. Stuart is a handsome man, and very nice. After we’d finished a bottle of wine (which Stuart chose), he suggested we go to a nearby restaurant (again, trendy, upscale) for dinner. We sat in an intimate booth in the corner, ordered another bottle of wine with our dinner (which we did not finish), and continued our pleasant, if somewhat boring, conversation. At 10:30, in the midst of his regaling me with trial stories, I told him I had to end the evening because the valet stopped working. After the valet brought my car around, Stuart and I sat on a bench in front of the restaurant and continued talking, or he continued talking, for another half hour or so. I found myself wishing he’d shut the hell up so I could go home to bed. At long last, he did, and we hugged goodbye. I felt nothing, other than relief that I could drive home and crawl into bed.

As I drove home, I found myself ruminating about Mack. And missing him terribly. While Stuart is many things Mack is not, Mack is many things Stuart is not. I was always very physically attracted to Mack. Even though Stuart is good-looking and fit (triathlete), I didn’t feel attracted to him. I also found talking with Stuart somewhat monotonous, and I was not disappointed when the night came to an end. When I was with Mack, I never wanted the night to end.

The next day I was tired. And emotional. I kept comparing Mack and Stuart, and tearing up in my office. Instead of making me feel good, spending time with Stuart had me feeling a terrible ache for Mack. It had me second-guessing my decision. It had me off-balance again. I had to make a concerted effort to remind myself why I’d broken things off with Mack. I fell asleep Thursday night crying, and I struggled to bring myself back to reality by thinking about Mack’s finances, Corinne, his temper, his moodiness, and his drinking (and my drinking when I was with him).

Spending time with Stuart did not help me move on from Mack. It made me sad and lonely and I missed Mack more than ever. Getting back on the horse too soon, even with a “non-date” date, is not a good idea. I was still too raw, too vulnerable, for it to have a positive effect. All it did was remind me how easy it was to be with Mack, how great our physical relationship was, and how fearful I am that I won’t have that again.

It seems it’s best to avoid dating, including “non-date” dates, for a while longer. Otherwise, it’ll end up like Wednesday night, and the horse will go charging across the field to the nearest tree with a low-hanging branch, knocking me out of the saddle, and flat on my ass once again. Yeah, I need to pick myself up, dust myself off, and stay the hell away from horses for a while.

 

Next Page »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 229 other followers